About a month ago I bought a new '08 KP 8-ball. I looked at a couple of Vics before choosing that one - First, I thought I wanted a bagger, so the XRoad was my first choice. I test-rode it, and although it handled beautifully for its size, I wasn't ready for a bike of that size.
So I went for the muscle cruisers. They had a Vegas that was on sale, and the test ride went very well. But I did want the option of bags that would look good, and it seemed that the Vegas was a little harder to accessorize the way I wanted to (lots of the bags wouldn't flow with the rear fender). So by the time I sunk the money into it to make it look the way I wanted with slash pipes, etc., the sale price was for naught.
So then we looked at the bike that first caught my eye - the PinBall. The one they had was already accessorized with the blacked-out turndown pipes, teardrop mirrors, backrest, and lay-down billet plate with LEDs. It was, to me, by far the sexiest bike on the floor. I was a little hesitant about losing that 6th gear - and I'll tell ya, there's plenty of times I'm in 5th and stomping on it looking for the nonexistent 6th, as I did in my Vulcan - but even at 80 mph, if you lay on it, she's still got PLENTY and will jump into action. So no complaints from me on the performance, although I'll admit I'm not a speed demon.
I actually test rode the standard KP, even though it wasn't the style I was going for. The PinBall was up on a dias and they said the ride was basically the same between the two. To me, they look like completely different bikes. I did have to have it lowered, and let me tell you - everybody tells me how menacing and sexy the bike looks all blacked out and low. I have added a black fade windshield, and my multi-bar (black of course) just arrived. Ooh, and a black flame luggage rack. So I'm trying to keep it sleek and as black as possible. It turns a LOT of heads. Old Harley guys, metric riders, everybody asks me about it. I've become a bike nite regular just because I like to see them all puzzling over exactly what the heck I'm riding! I also get a lot of "Batmobile" comments.
One thing I'm loving - not babysitting a ton of chrome! I have a black car, and my previous bike was black cherry. I haven't found that keeping a black bike clean is as difficult as my car, unless you get caught in the rain. I am partial to black bikes though.
Sorry for the diatribe, but there are a lot of factors to consider, and I was just in your shoes a month ago! See my gallery for recent photos, and my last advice is to go with your gut!
Good luck!